In my 35+ years of ministry I’ve had many good friends who weren’t clergy. In fact, while I’ve had lots of good friends who are pastors, most of my best friends (golfing, fishing buddies) have been laymen. One thing that has helped that relationship is that they thought of me as a friend and not as a pastor. That isn’t to say we never interacted at that level, but there was a sense of mutuality about it.
However, I’ve known some good men with whom I couldn’t have that level of friendship because they could never forget that I was a pastor. We could be right in the middle of laughing about something and they’d say, “I can’t believe a pastor would think that’s funny.” When I hear something like that I reevaluate my relationship with that person. They aren’t ready to be a real “friend” to the pastor. I adjust things so I can treat them as a person in need of a pastor. I guess you’d say I stop being “one of the guys” in a group of Christian friends and move back to the pastor position so I can minister to them the best I am able.
In fact, I think wanting to “be friends” with “the pastor” is almost self defeating. If someone wants to be friends with me, a person with whom they have something in common (like fishing for bass or hiking) that’s one thing. If they want to be friends with “the pastor” well, that carries with it, at least in my way of thinking, considerable baggage. After all, I don’t think to myself, “I’d like to be friends with ‘the doctor’ or with ‘the policeman.'” Rather, I view them as people and not vocations.